Products Lemma APIProof issuance & verification platformTrust402Delegate to agents, and transactSealSign-in for the agent era — no keys handed over
Use cases Manufacturing & Critical InfraInspection Record AssuranceFinance & FinTechCounterparty Record VerificationPublic SectorCertificate-less ProceduresHealthcareQualified Worker AssuranceProcurement & Supply ChainSupplier Credential MonitoringMedia & ContentContent AuthenticityService & RetailCross-group IdentityAI Adoption (cross-industry)AI Run GovernanceDevelopers & Agent OpsAgent Authority Control ▸ Browse the use-case index
Pricing
Resources Critical BriefThe frontier of AI × trustBlogThinking and implementation notesDocumentationAPI & specsVerification CenterReal verification & issuance countsAbout usFRAME00, Inc.ContactSales & press inquiriesGlossaryDefinitionsFAQFrequently asked questions
Dashboard ↗ JA
Home / Critical Brief / No. 171
No. 171 Critical Brief · Regulatory Attribute Proof

Free Mobile and Free: Subscribers' personal data was accessed, and keeping former subscribers' data was also found unlawful (CNIL sanction)

24million
Subscriber contracts whose personal data was accessed (including IBANs)
€42million
Total fines (FREE MOBILE €27M, FREE €15M)
6months
Deadline set for FREE MOBILE to sort and delete former subscribers' data
CountryFrance
Incident date2026-01-13
Published2026-11-05
AuthorsLemma Critical Team
Contents
  1. 01Summary
  2. 02What got through
  3. 03Pre-execution check
  4. 04What Lemma does
  5. 05Facts and timeline
  6. 06Sources

Summary

  1. 01What happened

    In October 2024 an attacker got into both companies’ information systems and accessed subscriber personal data (CNIL). CNIL found two different things in this sanction. One is the entry point and detection: authentication for the remote-work VPN was not robust enough, and detection of abnormal behaviour was ineffective.

  2. 02What was found

    The other is former subscribers’ data: there was no way to sort it, and millions of pieces of data were kept without justification (FREE MOBILE only). Whether former subscribers’ data was among what was accessed has not been disclosed.

  3. 03Why it got through

    Personal data you hold, even if unused, is within reach of anyone who gets into the system.

Figure 1Detection vs. a pre-execution check

Pre-execution check = before subscriber data is read, checking that the read is within the permission and the retention deadline, and recording it. Detection = noticing after the read has happened. The dates below are the month of the intrusion and the dates of CNIL's procedure; the day of the intrusion has not been disclosed.

Pre-execution check · not known from the disclosuresBefore a read, check it is within the permission and the retention deadline
What was confirmedPersonal data of 24 million contracts
including IBANs
Detection · as found by CNILDetection of abnormal behaviour was ineffective
2024-10
Attacker gets into the information systems
2026-01-08
CNIL's restricted committee deliberates
2026-01-13
CNIL imposes the sanctions
2026-01-14
CNIL publishes

What got through

What got through
In October 2024 an attacker got into both companies’ information systems and accessed personal data relating to 24 million subscriber contracts (CNIL), including IBANs of individuals who were customers of both companies.
What was found about the entry point
The VPN authentication procedure for remote work was not sufficiently robust, measures to detect abnormal behaviour on the information systems were ineffective, and certain basic security measures that could have made the attack harder were not in place (CNIL).
What reaches the receiving side
In general, a login through the VPN arrives as a connection from a legitimate internal user. How much subscriber data that connection may read cannot be told from the login alone.
Not disclosed
How the attacker got through the VPN (for example, how credentials were obtained), how the data was read out, whether former subscribers’ data was included, how many years and how many records of former subscribers’ data were kept, the split between the two companies, and the number of IBANs.

Pre-execution check

The condition that holds whatever the route is that a read of personal data is checked, apart from the reader and before it runs, against the permitted party, purpose and volume and the retention deadline.

Pre-execution gate
Before reading subscriber data, check the read against the permitted range and the retention deadline, not the entry-point login.
Who approves
The organisation that manages the personal data. For each kind of data, it decides and records the permitted party, purpose and range of reads, and the retention deadline. For former subscribers it keeps only items with a reason, such as accounting, with a deadline.
Where the check sits
In front of reads of subscriber data. Cap the number of records and the range one read can reach. Hold reads beyond the permission or past the retention deadline until checked.
What is left behind
A record of which permission each read relied on and whose data was read, kept apart from the reader’s own actions in a form that can later be shown to a third party.

Entry-point authentication and how long data is kept are separate controls; when one works, the gap in the other remains. Cases where data collected for identity checks was still being kept include Coinbase, Discord and IDScan.net.

What Lemma does

Lemma builds the pre-execution check in front of reads of subscriber data. It neither deletes data nor looks for intrusions; it checks, before execution, that a read is within the permission and the retention deadline.

Industries and operations to watch

IndustryServices & retail
services such as telecoms that hold bank details for large numbers of subscribers for monthly direct debits. Counting people who have left, the data held exceeds the number of current subscribers.
OperationLookup & data access
work that pulls subscriber data through internal screens or remote connections. If the login alone decides how much a connection that got in can read, the readable range is all the data held.

Current controls vs Lemma

The disclosed route in this case is column 2 (entry-point login); how the data was read (column 3) has not been disclosed. Column 1 is the retention issue CNIL found in the same decision; its relation to the scope of this breach has not been disclosed.

Control Keeping former subscribers’ data Entry-point login (remote-work VPN) Reading subscriber data
Sorting and deleting former subscribers’ data Effective Not relevant Partial
Stronger VPN authentication Not relevant Partial Not relevant
Detecting abnormal behaviour Not relevant Partial Partial
Lemma (pre-execution check) Not relevant Not relevant Partial

Sorting and deleting former subscribers’ data stops holding data with no reason to keep it and shrinks what can be read after a break-in, but does not stop reads of the current subscribers’ data that is kept (CNIL ordered FREE MOBILE to finish within six months). Stronger VPN authentication narrows who can get in, but lets through anyone holding legitimate credentials. Detecting abnormal behaviour can work at both the entry and the read, but notices after the fact, and CNIL found it ineffective here. Lemma checks a read against the permission and the retention deadline before it runs.

Note: Lemma’s check works only when it is built into the path through which subscriber data is read, with the permitted party, purpose and volume and the retention deadline managed apart from the reader. Reads from outside that path, such as reading the database directly, do not pass through it. Deleting data is the job of the organisation that holds it; Lemma does not reduce what is stored. How the attacker got through the entry point and how the data was read have not been disclosed; this Brief will be revised if a later report discloses them. The table compares what each control checks; it does not show whether this incident would have been stopped. Lemma does not detect or prevent intrusions.

CheckChecklist

Three questions about subscriber data

  • Can you say which systems still hold former customers’ data, and which items?
  • At remote-work entry points, do you confirm the person or device logging in, in addition to the password?
  • If a large volume of subscriber data were about to be read at once, could you stop it before the read?

Facts and timeline

Authority’s decision
Deliberations SAN-2026-001 and SAN-2026-002 of CNIL’s restricted committee (2026-01-08). Sanctions imposed on 2026-01-13, published on 2026-01-14.
Fines
€27 million on FREE MOBILE and €15 million on FREE (€42 million in total). FREE MOBILE and FREE are each the controller for their own subscribers’ data.
Incident
In October 2024 an attacker got into both companies’ information systems and accessed personal data relating to 24 million subscriber contracts, including IBANs of individuals who were customers of both companies. By publication, CNIL had received more than 2,500 complaints.
Security (GDPR Art. 32, both companies)
The remote-work VPN authentication procedure was not sufficiently robust, and measures to detect abnormal behaviour were ineffective. Certain basic security measures that could have made the attack harder were not in place (as found by CNIL).
Notifying individuals (GDPR Art. 34, both companies)
The notification email lacked information required by Art. 34(2), so individuals could not grasp the consequences or the steps open to them (as found by CNIL).
Storage limitation (GDPR Art. 5(1)(e), FREE MOBILE only)
At inspection there was no way to sort former subscribers’ data, and millions of pieces of data were kept without justification (as found by CNIL).

Glossary
CNIL — France's data protection authority (Commission nationale de l'informatique et des libertés). It sanctions GDPR violations.
Storage limitation (GDPR Art. 5(1)(e)) — The principle that personal data must not be kept in identifiable form longer than needed for its purpose.
IBAN — An internationally used bank account number, used for direct debits.

Timeline

  • An attacker gets into both companies’ information systems.
  • CNIL’s restricted committee deliberates (SAN-2026-001 and 002).
  • CNIL sanctions both companies.
  • CNIL publishes.

The facts here rest on CNIL’s publication. The findings of violations are CNIL’s; this Brief does not assess the companies’ handling. CNIL’s publication does not record either company’s arguments. The entry route, how the data was read, whether former subscribers’ data was included, and how long and how many records were kept have not been disclosed. What has not been disclosed does not mean there were no controls.

After disclosure

  • During the proceedings: Both companies strengthened security, and FREE MOBILE began sorting former subscribers’ data. It kept only data needed for accounting, for ten years, and deleted some of the excess (CNIL).
  • CNIL’s orders: Both companies must complete the new security measures within three months. FREE MOBILE must complete sorting and deleting the data within six months of notification of the decision.

Sources

  1. Primary, authorityCNIL “Data breach: FREE MOBILE and FREE fined €42 million”2026-01-14 · cnil.fr/en/sanction-free-2026

This Brief uses only CNIL’s publication as primary. The full decisions (SAN-2026-001 and 002) and the companies’ own statements have not been checked. Press and commentary sites are not included as sources.

The same method elsewhereSee all 21 "Account takeover" cases

This Brief sets out, from disclosed facts, what organisations in a similar position can check. It is not guidance on individual losses or procedures.

This material is a structured analysis of public information; it is not an audit, diagnosis, or recommendation for any specific organization.

Cite this Brief

Lemma Critical Team. (2026).
"Free Mobile and Free: Subscribers' personal data was accessed, and keeping former subscribers' data was also found unlawful (CNIL sanction)".
Lemma Critical Brief No.171. Lemma / FRAME00, Inc.
https://lemma.frame00.com/critical/briefs/171-free-mobile-cnil-former-subscriber-retention/
Read nextNext
All Briefs →
Lemma

If it can't be verified,
it doesn't enter your operation.

Lemma is a pre-execution check: logins, payments, records and publishing that look genuine are checked before they run, with cryptographic proofs the receiving side verifies without asking the issuer. Detection stays; the check sits in front of it.